Consumer Reports GreenerChoices Consumer Reports GreenerChoices
GreenerChoices.org -- Join our FREE e-mail newsletter
HOME LABELS & CLAIMS - ECO-LABELS SUPPORT US


Greener Choices Home > Food-labeling poll 2008 > Water filters: Green buying guide 5/07

  Water filters: Green buying guide 5/07


Making green choices
How to choose
Assessing your needs
Making the right choice
Getting the most value
  Why it matters
  Green Ratings
Specific issues
  What government & industry are doing

Print this section
Green Ratings    Water filters

Listed in order of overall score, which is based mainly on the cartridges' effectiveness in removing chloroform, lead, and bad-taste, as well as flow rate and resistance to clogging. You can sort the ratings chart by any column by clicking on the header of the column.

Ratings last updated: May 2007
Click [i] for more information
Brand and model
Click for more informationPrice
Click for more informationOverall score
Test results
Filter-life indicator
Click for more information
Filter cost/yr.
Click for more information
Lead removal
Click for more information
Chloroform removal
Click for more information
Flow rate
Click for more information
Clogging
Click for more information
Bad-taste removal
Click for more information
CR Best Buy indicates an exceptional value


Carafes Store in the refrigerator.
Brita AquaLux
$25 68 Yes $48
Shaklee Perfect Pitcher 82301
$17 61 No $90
Pur Ultimate CR-900
$25 48 Yes $90
Brand and model
Click for more informationPrice
Click for more informationOverall score
Test results
Filter-life indicator
Click for more information
Filter cost/yr.
Click for more information
Lead removal
Click for more information
Chloroform removal
Click for more information
Flow rate
Click for more information
Clogging
Click for more information
Bad-taste removal
Click for more information
Faucet-mounted filters Attach to the faucet by removing the aerator.
Pur Horizontal FM9400
$40 63 Yes $80
GE SmartWater GFXMO3C (Home Depot)
$20 54 No $64
Brita Disposable CKFF-100
$40 50 Yes $0
Onmi F1
$20 35 No $40
Brand and model
Click for more informationPrice
Click for more informationOverall score
Test results
Filter-life indicator
Click for more information
Filter cost/yr.
Click for more information
Lead removal
Click for more information
Chloroform removal
Click for more information
Flow rate
Click for more information
Clogging
Click for more information
Bad-taste removal
Click for more information
Countertop filters Attach to the faucet by removing the aerator.
Kenmore (Sears) 34551 A CR Best Buy
$50 91 No $20
Shaklee Best Water MTS2000
$255 88 No $105
e-Spring 100188
$575 87 Yes $173
Culligan CT-2
$50 72 No $75
Brand and model
Click for more informationPrice
Click for more informationOverall score
Test results
Filter-life indicator
Click for more information
Filter cost/yr.
Click for more information
Lead removal
Click for more information
Chloroform removal
Click for more information
Flow rate
Click for more information
Clogging
Click for more information
Bad-taste removal
Click for more information
Undersink filters Require plumbing, sink, or countertop changes.
Aqua Pure by Cuno, AP-DWS1000
$350 88 Yes $180
Kenmore (Sears) 38454 A CR Best Buy
$55 88 No $34
Culligan SY-2650
$165 86 Yes $90
Kenmore (Sears) 38460
$85 83 No $46
Omni CBF-3
$115 82 No $330
GE SmartWater GXSV65F (Home Depot)
$150 78 Yes $80
Whirlpool Gold WHED20 (Lowe’s)
$110 78 Yes $90
Everpure H-300 single
$300 71 Yes $95
Brand and model
Click for more informationPrice
Click for more informationOverall score
Test results
Filter-life indicator
Click for more information
Filter cost/yr.
Click for more information
Lead removal
Click for more information
Chloroform removal
Click for more information
Flow rate
Click for more information
Clogging
Click for more information
Bad-taste removal
Click for more information
Reverse-osmosis filters Require plumbing, sink, or countertop changes.
Kenmore (Sears) Elite 38556
$300 75 Yes $80
Whirlpool Gold WHER25 (Lowe’s) A CR Best Buy
$160 74 Yes $62
Culligan Good Water Machine AC30
$900 73 No $50
GE Profile SmartWater PXRQ15F (Home Depot)
$260 72 Yes $100
Brand and model
Click for more informationPrice
Click for more informationOverall score
Test results
Filter-life indicator
Click for more information
Filter cost/yr.
Click for more information
Lead removal
Click for more information
Chloroform removal
Click for more information
Flow rate
Click for more information
Clogging
Click for more information
Bad-taste removal
Click for more information
Whole-house filters Require plumbing changes but none at the sink or faucet.
Whirlpool WHCF-DWHV (Lowe’s)
$35 43 No $24
GE SmartWater GXWH20F (Home Depot)
$35 42 Yes $32
Kenmore (Sears) 38440
$45 42 No $18
Brand and model
Click for more informationPrice
Click for more informationOverall score
Test results
Filter-life indicator
Click for more information
Filter cost/yr.
Click for more information
Lead removal
Click for more information
Chloroform removal
Click for more information
Flow rate
Click for more information
Clogging
Click for more information
Bad-taste removal
Click for more information
Not recommended Sample problems included clogs, leaks, and high levels of ozone.
Lotus Tersano LWT100 (Carafe)
$150 55 Yes $40
Learn even more about
product performance
by subscribing to


About GreenerChoices.org   |   Newsroom   |   Your privacy rights   |   Security   |   Contact us
Copyright © 2003-2010 by Consumers Union of United States., Inc., 101 Truman Avenue, Yonkers, NY 10703, a nonprofit organization. No downloading, transmission, photocopying, or commercial use permitted. Visit www.GreenerChoices.org.